Some Chapter 380 person of earnestness, really good!( Asked monthly ticket) 第380章有人较真,真好！(求月票) The judgment of first instance, the fact showed that many people are paying attention to this case. 一审判决出来了,事实证明,还是有不少人在关注这个案子的。 Mainly is everyone wants to see the operator educated situation. 主要是大家都想看到运营商被教育的情况。 Then the discovery, did the first trial only win the penalty unexpectedly? 然后便发现,一审居然只赢了违约金？ This makes many people think that is uncomfortable. 这就让很多人觉得不舒服了。 side Xiaoying in high-intensity has eaten the melon this period of time, with oneself that „greatly sparkling” account number unceasing and person chatted. 方小莹这段时间一直在高强度吃瓜,用自己那个“大莹莹”的账号不断的和人聊天。 Now also realizes, truly cannot castigate the people of many rights protection. 现在也意识到了,确实不能对很多维权的人进行苛责。 Since the stipulation is such, that must according to stipulating. 既然规定是那样的,那就得按照规定来。 Cannot, because said that possibly causes the interest of basic unit staff to be damaged does not do, that insisted saying that basically our many complaints, were the basic unit staff is a scapegoat finally. 不能因为说可能导致基层员工的利益受损就不做了,那硬要说起来,基本上我们的很多投诉,最后都是基层员工背锅。 You said that this can't sue? 那你说这就不能投诉了吗？ Because this time event is very special, the amount is small, but affects in a big way, therefore created such big discussion. 只是因为这次的事件很特殊,金额小,但是影响大,所以造成了这么大的议论。 Therefore after the judgment of first instance, side Xiaoying then expressed own view quickly. 因此在一审判决出来后,方小莹很快便发表了自己的看法。 „This is unreasonable, doesn't need also to make a payment? No matter which aspect looked that is not right, why?” “这不合理吧,不用了还得给交钱？不管哪个方面看都不对吧,凭什么啊？” An impression as normal person is this, I used your service to you money, is very normal. 作为一个正常人的观感就是这样,我用了你的服务给你钱,很正常。 However I prepared the cancellation you also to collect this money, that was not definitely right. 但是我都准备销号了伱还收这个钱,那肯定不对。 However was seeing that the ascending staff made the appeal also to feel at ease slightly, at least ascended such just. 不过在看到腾达员工提起了上诉也稍微心安了点,最起码腾达还是那么的刚。 This made her think of own matter, the issue that but came across was more complex, can actually consider, how to come, was not clear. 这让她想到了自己的事,可自己遇到的问题更复杂,究竟能不能告,怎么来告,都不清楚。 Upturned many in the net, has not seen similar case. 在网上翻了好多,从来都没有见过类似的案例。 This makes side Xiaoying very hesitant. 这让方小莹很犹豫。 This year's in July she will graduate, or first ascends to practise a wave? 今年的七月份她就会毕业,那要不先去腾达实习一波？ That „Jingzhou is greatly intelligent” in the article has said explicitly, this company, the intern can still use the legal aid service even. 那个“京州大聪明”的文章里可是明确说过的,这家公司,就算是实习生也可以使用法律援助服务。 The second trial holds court to return sometime, the online public opinion also subsided gradually, once again was occupied by various types of entertainment stories. 二审开庭还有段时间,网上的舆论也渐渐平息了下来,又一次被各种娱乐新闻所占据。 Someone divorced, someone spiked a rumour, in any case various chaos. 谁谁谁离婚了,谁谁谁辟谣了,反正各种纷乱。 Especially now, the online changing situation is too rapid, current capacity stars you sang me to arrive. 尤其是现在,网上的情况变化太快,流量明星们你方唱罢我登场。 It seems like one hair same current capacity star, you do not know that who is, but looked that the online situation feels they probably very red appearance. 很多看起来一毛一样的流量明星,你都不知道谁是谁,但看网上的情况就是感觉他们好像很红的样子。 Then many people are eating the melon, oneself are bewildered there, who this fellow, I how has not heard...... 然后好多人都在吃瓜,自己在那里莫名其妙,这家伙谁啊,我咋从来没听说过呢…… During is like this complex, the second trial will soon hold court. 在这样的纷繁之中,第二审即将开庭。 Chen Wenjing reads in the petition of appeal transcription the name face delay of opposite party attorney, is not Zhang Wei and kingly way benevolent, how to become side Xujing now? 只是陈文景看着起诉状副本中对方律师的名字一脸呆滞,不是张伟和王道仁吗,怎么现在又成了方许镜了？ Person the shadow of famous tree, Zhang Wei kingly way benevolent this is the nameless junior, needless to say. 人的名树的影,张伟王道仁这是无名小辈,自不必说。 However who side Xujing is, that is the reputation remoteness is good! 但是方许镜是什么人,那是声名远扬好嘛！ Before is not no need to say in the demon, passed through these two years after Jingzhou, the reputation was instead bigger than before. 以前在魔都就不必说了,在京州经过了这两年之后,名声反而比之前更大。 Many of Supreme Court used this by the case interpretation classical case, this on behalf of what obviousness! 最高法的多起以案释法经典案例都是用了这位的,这代表着什么显而易见！ The most important thing is, 30-year-old Chen Wenjing, had also listened to the class of this Teacher side initially...... 最重要的是,今年30多岁的陈文景,当初也是听过这位方老师的课…… But any class that has listened to side Dazhuang, that will basically have felt his suffocating debate method. 而凡是听过方大状的课,那基本上都会感受过他那种让人窒息的辩论方法。 Doesn't that win, but according to will rub on the ground your intelligence quotient, making you feel, I why so stupid...... 那不是赢不赢,而是会把你的智商按在地上摩擦,让你感觉,我为什么这么笨…… Did not speak Wu De, did not speak Wu De, hasn't the first trial won the second trial to change the attorney? 不讲武德,不讲武德啊,一审没赢下来二审就换律师？ Has to think to flinch, but without the means that he is the law, receives the wages, whom this matter he drew back made get up. 有心想退缩,但是没办法,他是法务,是领工资的,这种事他退了让谁上。 Only can prepare diligently, if won when the time comes, that will be prestigious...... 只能更加努力地准备,而如果到时候赢了,那是不是就会声名大噪呢…… However, the results show that when the disparity of person as big as certain extent, this does not have the means to make up diligently. 然而,实践表明,当人的差距大到一定程度的时候,这是努力没办法弥补的。 On the second trial court, Chen Wenjing vision has a delay. 第二审法庭上,陈文景的目光有着一丝呆滞。 Opposite side big shape calmly sits, often takes up the drinking glass to drink water, a smile of face. 对面的方大状静静坐着,不时地拿起水杯喝口水,一脸的微笑。 The time side Dazhuang look that enters the court is not quite right, looks that he looked like the hunter to see the prey was the same. 进法庭的时候方大状的眼神就不太对,看着他就像是猎人看到了猎物一样。 In just, two people ended the forensic argument. 就在刚刚,两人结束了法庭辩论。 The one who lets him not think, opposite side big shape abandoned the factor of form provision completely, but debated from code civil basic principle. 让他没想到的是,对面的方大状完全摒弃了格式条款的因素,只是从民法典基本原则方面来进行辩论。 The most simple truth, I do not need to pay money uselessly, is so simple. 最浅显的道理,我没用就不需要付钱,就这么简单。 However with such simple truth, actually refutes dumbfounded him. 但是用这么简单的道理,却把他驳斥地哑口无言。 Changed the service not to provide from the form provision the argument focus whether should pay expenses on. 把争论焦点从格式条款上转移到了服务没提供是否应该缴费上。 Your form provision are even many, this thing it can regard as a contract of service. 你就算是格式条款再多,这东西它就可以看做一个服务合同。 But the service has not provided, that does not need to make a payment. 而服务没提供,那就是不需要交钱。 The second trial changed the original judgment, the ruling supports Wu De's complete demand, no matter penalty or monthly rent. 二审改判了,判决支持吴德的全部诉求,不管是违约金还是月租。 Naturally, the ruling between court and court is not same, if this point studies diligently some ruling to know carefully. 当然,法院和法院之间的判决也不是一样,这一点如果仔细钻研过一些判决就能知道。 According to some fact suitable law is different, the result that obtains possibly is also different. 根据某个事实适用的法律不同,那得到的结果也可能不同。 In the visitors'gallery, Zhou Yixiao, side Dazhuang that is preparing this lawsuit this period of time wholeheartedly. 旁听席上,周毅笑了,方大状这段时间那可是全心全意地在准备这个官司。 side Dazhuang is earnest, that basically did not have others anything matter. 方大状认真起来,那基本上就没别人什么事了。 However this Chen Wenjing is good, at least the level, can resist such several rounds with side Dazhuang. 不过这个陈文景还算不错,最起码水平可以,能和方大状对抗那么几回合。 But no matter how, this lawsuit finally won! 但不管如何,这个官司终于是赢了！ The kingly way benevolent and Zhang Wei also audited, they must learn/study well, if under them the making a round trip plate, that will definitely think of this point. 王道仁和张伟同样来旁听了,他们还得好好学习,如果他们下来复盘,那肯定会想到这个点。 On however the court, you were very easy to have the rhythm. 但是上了法庭,你就很容易被带节奏。 The theory and practice forever are two matters, the week rookies are very typical examples. 理论和实践永远是两回事,周菜鸟就是很典型的例子。 The second trial won, in Jingzhou Branch, the related leader wants to curse at people. 二审赢了,京州分公司内,相关领导又想骂人了。 However without the means that the lawsuit lost lost, compared various rights protection methods, the court decision most had the effort! 但是没办法,官司输了就是输了,相比各种维权方法,法院判决是最有力度的！ side Xiaoying is very happy, solely is not because this lawsuit won, moreover she also discovered, facing some special lawsuits, by resolute that side Dazhuang, must be interested compared with their these litigants probably! 方小莹很开心,不单单是因为这个官司赢了,而且她还发现,面对一些特殊的官司,阿毅旁边那位方大状,好像比他们这些当事人还要感兴趣！ If has not seen the case...... 那如果是一个从来没见过的案子呢…… In the selling area, Manager Zhou and Li Xiaojie after seeing the ruling are also the surprise, immediately starts the feeling. 营业厅内,周经理和李晓洁在看到了判决结果后也是诧异,随即开始感慨。 This probably is recent many years of only one really the person who the legal way walks. 这大概是最近好多年唯一一个真的把法律途径走完的人吧。 Is good has released the statement after the company not again they how. 好在公司发过声明后也不会再把她俩怎么样。 However felt that this earnest does not need completely, because the lawsuit won, is that 138 dollars. 但是又感觉这较真完全没必要,因为官司赢了,也是那一百三十八块钱而已。 Will let move the company to lose a face. 只是会让挪动公司丢一点面子而已。 Even but if loses face again, moves company that mass, you do not have the means. 可就算再丢面子,挪动公司还是那个体量,你没办法的。 As for other Zhou's audience masters, feels gratified, resolute has started to do this company, that will later do, cannot think! 至于其他周某人的观众老爷,更是觉得欣慰,阿毅已经开始搞这种公司了,那以后会干嘛,都不敢想呢！ Another feeling is, but must side Dazhuang, be side Dazhuang is credible! 另一个感觉是,还得方大状,还是方大状靠谱！ You have a look at other these attorneys, what kingly way benevolent Zhang Wei, that looked that the hairstyle knows is not a powerhouse. 你看看其他的这些律师,什么王道仁张伟的,那看发型就知道不是强者。 In fact this similar case, you, if goes to the law firm to consult has known, actually does not have the attorney to be willing to meet. 事实上这种类似的案子,你要是去律所咨询过就知道,其实是没有律师愿意接的。 Because of background anything, pure was not the target was too small, others will tell you, did not meet. 不是因为背景什么,单纯是标的额太小了,人家会告诉你,不接。 So is noisily big, can above manage? 只是闹这么大,上面会不会管呢？ However was a pity very much, side Dazhuang one, oh...... 但是很可惜啊,方大状就一个,唉…… But in the meantime, informed to appear in quietly online, and in a short time led to the upsurge. 但就在此时,一则通知悄无声息地出现在了网上,并且在很短的时间内引发了热潮。 „Moves company Jingzhou Branch to obstruct the user cancellation about the net biography the matter, has noticed the related popular feelings, the man (Han) chancellery telecommunication management bureau has commenced the investigation......” “关于网传挪动公司京州分公司阻挠用户销号的事,已经注意到相关舆情,汉东省通信管理局已经介入调查……” Behind is some polite talk, for example has the issue to investigate surely. 后面就是一些套话,比如有问题必定追究。 This notice comes out, immediately initiated the netizen to discuss. 这通知一出来,顿时引发了网友热议。 What penalty anything monthly rent, this gave a pretext regarding the general netizens, the core of issue was not this money, but must obstruct the user cancellation through this money to come! 什么违约金什么月租,对于广大网友来说这都是借口,问题的核心不是这个钱,而是要通过这个钱来阻挠用户销号！ It is not many, but disgusting person! 是不多,但是恶心人！ Generally speaking, online published the circular of involvement investigation, that in fact starts to investigate certainly many that this is earlier. 一般来说,网上出了介入调查的通告,那实际上开始调查肯定要比这早的多。 Why regarding is not Ministry of Industry, that is because has not been one's turn this above big shot to act. 至于说为什么不是工信部,那是因为还轮不到这上面的大佬出面。 After all to put it bluntly is only an issue of Jingzhou. 毕竟说穿了只是京州的一个问题而已。 East the man (Han) moves in the headquarters, Hong could have ignored the vitality/angry. 汉东挪动公司总部内,洪总已经顾不上生气了。 „Since has started to investigate, that told them full power to coordinate, was the malicious obstruction, must the investigation be clear!” “既然已经开始调查,那告诉他们全力配合,是不是恶意阻挠,必须得调查清楚了！” Meanwhile, the man (Han) east company must start to investigate, before this is different from Zhou , other earnest enterprises. 与此同时,汉东公司也要开始调查,这是有别于周某人之前较真的其他企业。 Those words, something not on scale not four twofold, but once on the scale, that 1000 jin (0.5 kg) could not stop. 还是那句话,有的事不上秤没有四两重,可一旦上了秤,那一千斤都止不住。 Chen Wenjing returned to the company, the second trial to lose a lawsuit, it is no doubt that in the company the vice-president in charge of relevant operation will definitely criticize. 陈文景回到了公司,二审败诉,不用说,公司内分管相关业务的副总肯定会批评。 However does not have the means that is not as skillful as others. 但是没办法啊,技不如人。 Therefore Chen Wenjing can only think, waits for the approved time how has a look to suffer, the rebuttal is not possible. 所以陈文景只能想着,等会被批的时候看看怎么挨过去,反驳是不可能的。 In this situation you, if dares to refute, that criticism will be more ominous. 这种情况下你要是敢反驳,那批评的会更凶。 The result comes back quite a while not to have the sound, therefore dialed a very ripe colleague telephone. 结果回来半天都没动静,于是就拨通了一个很熟的同事电话。 „Why leads has not managed you? Oneself read the news, our leadership cannot attend to criticizing you now.” “为什么领导没管你？自己看新闻,咱们的领导现在都顾不上批评你了。” Reads the news? 看新闻吗？ Chen Wenjing hurries to access the net, saw the man (Han) chancellery telecommunication management bureau must launch the news of investigation, gawked, suddenly smiled. 陈文景赶紧上网,看到了汉东省通信管理局要展开调查的新闻,愣了一下,突然就笑了。 ............ ………… The spring footsteps had walked half, the weather warms up. 春天的脚步已经走了一半,天气转暖。 Moves the company second trial to judge that from Wu De the past, Wu De has been complaining. 距离吴德告挪动公司二审宣判已经过去一段时间了,吴德却一直在吐槽。 Although he is the litigant of this event, however, all media reports mentioned him, will say that he was the ascending staff. 尽管他是这个事件的当事人,但是呢,所有的媒体报道之时提到他,都会说他是腾达员工。 Name? Sorry, without name. 名字？抱歉,没有名字。 The present, many people knew some people, because 100 sued moved the company, actually does not know that who that plaintiff was. 以至于现在了,很多人都知道有人因为一百来块起诉了挪动公司,却不知道那个原告是谁。 The former Han dynasty chancellery telecommunication management bureau said that must investigate, did not have the result by the present, many people actually this matter forgetting. 之前汉东省通信管理局说要调查,到现在了也没结果,很多人其实都已经把这件事给忘了。 In the chairman office, Zhou resolute sits in inside, what outside sits is side Dazhuang. 董事长办公室内,周毅坐在里面,外面坐着的是方大状。 „Your this place is good, before saying me, has not paid attention to look!” side Dazhuang said with a smile. “你这地方不错啊,说起来我以前都没注意看呢！”方大状笑道。 He had come ascending before, but is the matter that works, has not sat down to come to see well. 他以前来过腾达,但都是工作上的事,还没有好好坐下来看呢。 Today is because has free time, therefore wants to come to see. 今天是因为有空,所以就想来看看。 What is more important, recently his research fell into the bottleneck, lacks the actual case, without the means that the case that he wanted is too rare. 更重要的是,最近他的研究陷入了瓶颈,缺少实际案例,没办法,他想要的案子太罕见了。 „Also gathers together.” Zhou resolute said with a smile: „Recently started to recruit the intern, therefore the person will be many.” “还凑和吧。”周毅笑道:“最近又开始招实习生了,所以人会多点。” Two people are chatting, suddenly Zhou resolute the cell phone made a sound, with looked, the discovery is the news that the Yuan elder sister sends. 两人正聊着呢,突然周毅的手机响了,拿起来一看,发现是媛姐发来的消息。 „Pigeon essence, the findings came out!” “鸽子精,调查结果出来了！” What findings, the time a little are long, even/including Zhouyi gave to forget. 什么调查结果,毕竟时间有点长,连周毅自己都给忘了。 Opens looks discovered, originally was the man (Han) chancellery telecommunication management bureau has given to moving the company the findings! 打开一看才发现,原来是汉东省通信管理局已经给出了对挪动公司的调查结果！ Carefully looked, can only say that this above punishment is very powerful! 仔细看了看,只能说这上面的处罚还是很给力啊！ „About moving the company Jingzhou Branch not warrant obstructs the investigation processing situation report of user cancellation!” “关于挪动公司京州分公司无正当理由阻挠用户销号的调查处理情况通报！” Actually pure is the punishment of communications company, only has 50,000 Yuan. 其实单纯是通信公司的处罚也就罢了,只有五万元。 But following also has the punishment of man (Han) chancellery company! 但随之而来的还有汉东省公司的处罚！ General Manager model/pattern in Jingzhou Branch, and vice-president of being in charge, the administrators below Guangming District Branch, that really bore the punishment from top to bottom. 京州分公司的范总经理,以及分管的副总,还有下面光明区分公司的管理人员,那真的是从上到下都背上了处分。 The commentary area has exploded. 评论区已经爆炸了。 „Fog grass, who added that this does not have the significance earnestly, who can believe that because of more than 100 dollars, such a group of people was also warned finally does.” “雾草,谁还说这较真没意义的,谁能信呢,就因为一百多块钱,结果这么一堆人又是被警告又是干嘛的。” „Really, I thought that needs to be many some earnest people, you looked that the present many companies do not do the human affairs, should govern them well!” “真的,我就觉得需要多一些较真的人,你看现在的好多公司都不干人事,就应该好好治治他们！” The matter that „before who said that will not have the result to come, making bullet flying a while not good? The investigation also requires the time!” “之前谁说的这事会没结果来着,让子弹飞一会儿不行吗？调查也需要时间的！” This is some opinions before rebuttal, said that moves the company is the biological son, how to possibly punish. 这是在反驳之前的一些言论,说挪动公司是亲儿子,怎么可能会处罚呢。 Definitely turns big problems into small ones and small ones into no problems at all. 肯定是大事化小小事化了。 Finally, the fine was the small, bottom-up public criticism may not be the minor matter. 结果呢,罚款是小,从上到下的通报批评可就不是小事了。 In the selling area, Manager Zhou noticed that the process result quick compelled ignorant, her employed so many years, but also sees such situation for the first time. 营业厅内,周经理看到处理结果都快懵逼了,她从业这么多年,还第一次见到这样的情况。 If we had known today, initially their here newspapers time, can above directly deal with? 如果早知道今天,当初她们这里报上去的时候,上面会不会直接进行处理呢？ However now, the regret, is good because of their these basic unit staff late is not affected. 但是现在,后悔已经晚了,好在她们这些基层员工是不受影响的。 Content in the findings is very detailed, solely is not the penalty, contrary „present” meal issue. 调查结果里的内容很详细,不单单是违约金,还有违规“赠送”套餐的问题。 Because according to moving the stipulation of company, the meal of this nature must make the opposite party agree! 因为按照挪动公司的规定,这种性质的套餐是必须要让对方同意的！ But after passing through this event time, Jingzhou many people discovered, handling cancellation and Xie transferred the net to be easier to do! 而经过了这一次的事件之后,京州很多人发现,办理销号和携号转网好办多了！ They handled the cancellation, handles transfers various net difficulties with, is not this meal is that matter, wants the penalty. 原本他们办理销号,办理携号转网各种困难,不是这个套餐就是那个事,都是要违约金的。 Moreover sometimes obviously is several months of meal, must transfer the net to lengthen with suddenly. 而且有时候明明是几个月的套餐,要携号转网呢突然就变长了。 Now was good, online direct appointment, managed very smooth. 现在好了,网上直接预约,办的十分顺利。 Some person of earnestness, really good. 有人较真,真好。 The intern who the Tengda Corporation entrance, prepares to interview has lined up. 腾达公司门口,准备面试的实习生已经排成了队。 side Xiaoying a face that catches up with from the demon is specially firm, even for that case, I must enter ascends! 专门从魔都赶来的方小莹一脸坚定,就算为了那个案子,我也要进腾达！ Third, thank stonemen, another new big brother, the fat cat story big brother, big brother writing idiot, unsurprisingly, this case was considered as in black, not possibly thought at all......, but, actual case, but has not sued, punished anything real, before transferred the net to have difficultly with not to know that in practice, seeking the company may compared with the novel in brave, has not extended 20 years the meal deadline after the permission directly, then carried to transfer the net to be paid the penalty, you said in novel I do not dare to write...... in reality case, that. The number is the number.. 第三更,感谢stonemen,又一个新手大哥,肥猫物语大哥,文痴大哥,不出意外,这个案子又被认为是在黑,认为根本不可能……可是,实际案例,只是没有起诉,处罚什么的都是真的,之前携号转网有多难不会不知道吧,实际中,谋公司可比小说里胆大,直接未经过许可把套餐期限延长二十年,然后携号转网让付违约金的,你说小说里我都不敢这么写的……不过现实案例里,那个号是靓号。。 ( This chapter ends) (本章完)