SomeChapter 343peopleare living, hehas died
第343章有的人活着,他已经死了Broadcity, Yuanelder sisterover the two daysbeen maddoes not wantto access the net.
广市,媛姐这两天已经被气的不想上网了。Mainlyshereallydoes not wantto seemoralkidnapping that onlinethatblots out the sky.
主要她实在不想看到网上那铺天盖地的道德绑架。Moreover, shereallydid not have the means saying that the hatred for the richplot that our presentedyoumustreallysay, the reasonwere many.
而且,她是真的没办法说,我们这出现的仇富情节你要真的说起来,原因很多。
There is no wayto debate, can only sayresolutedefinitelyis notsuchsituation, howeverin such a case, whocomes outto debateone, will be really spurted the explosion.
这点就没法去辩论,只能说阿毅肯定不是那样的情况,但是在这样的情况下,谁出来辩一句,真的是会被喷到爆炸的。
The resultis just aggrieved, discoveredthissuddennotice, includingwas lookingtwo, the Yuanelder sisterswere shocked.
结果正憋屈呢,就发现了这个突然出现的通知,连着看了两遍,媛姐都惊呆了。
Has resoluteoriginalcontributed? Whatalsocontributesis the school?
阿毅原来早就捐过了?还捐的是学校?Why didn't hesay?
那他为什么不说呢?But the Yuanelder sistersoonhad the answer, she has gone toJingzhouandresolutehas met, and has eaten meal, in additionWeChat, between both sideswill often chat.
只不过媛姐很快就有了答案,她是去过京州和阿毅见过面的,而且还吃过饭,加了微信,双方之间经常会聊天。Thereforeaboutthisflat headelder brothera littleknew, heis the man who thattypewill workwill not care aboutothersview.
所以对这个平头哥还是有点了解的,他是那种做事情不会在意别人看法的男人。Heis earnest, forbyoneselfthattonealong, was thoughtnow the presenting the factsreasonablepersonare too few!
他较真,就是为了让自己那口气顺了,就是觉得现在摆事实讲道理的人太少了!Because the good peoplealwaysthis and thatreasonwere bullied, endingthinks that the rights protection must be so troublesome.
好人总是因为这样那样的原因被人欺负,完了想维权还得那么麻烦。Thereforehewantsto work asthatsheatfish, makingtheseunscrupulouspeoplehavein that littlethissocietyto havelikehimexistence, will standandothersis reasonable!
所以他就想当那条鲶鱼,让那些肆无忌惮的人有那么一点点这个社会上还是有像他这样的存在,会站出来和别人讲道理!Facts showed that resolutedoesis very good.
事实证明,阿毅做的很不错。Manypeople„will have the skillyougo to”and so on wordsto say.
原本呢,很多人都会把“有本事你就去告”之类的话挂在嘴边。Even the custom services of some manycompaniesarethis, youandtheyspoke the law, spoke the stipulation, theywill finally always say that youwent.
甚至不乏有一些公司的客服都是这样,你和他们讲法律,讲规定,他们最后总是会说,那伱去告吧。Butnow, thissituationwas shortcompared withbefore.
而现在,这种情况比起以前来说少了很多。Becauseresolutevideomakesmanypeoplesee,probably the courtis nottheyimaginesis so mystical, did not mean that anything will want the court is very troublesome.
因为阿毅的视频让很多人看到,好像法院并不是他们想象中那么神秘,并不是说任何事只要去了法院都会特别麻烦。On the contrary, manypeopleareon the mouthhard, whenyoureallygo to the courtto considerhim, reallyletshereceived the subpoena the time, hecompared withsending the countrywill surrender a quickerspeedto recognizebyonetypeinstigated.
相反,很多人都是嘴上硬,当你真的去法院告他,真的让他收到了传票的时候,他会以一种比发国投降更快的速度认怂。Yourthisconceals was also too deepfeeds, thatothernetredstardonated money, wished one couldto go out„donates moneyfourcharacterscarvingme”on the face.
只是,你这藏得也太深了吧喂,那别的网红明星捐款了,恨不得出门都把“我捐款了”四个字给刻在脸上。After allnowadays, so long asdonated money, thatmayhaveto exemptspurts the power.
毕竟这年头,只要捐款了,那可就有免喷权的。Even ifdoesagainmany not goodmatters, so long asdonates money, othersfanscanwash, yousaidunexpectedlymy familyloves the bean, yousaid that hisso manyissues, have youcontributedseveral cents?
哪怕做再多不好的事,只要捐了款,人家的粉丝就能洗地,你居然说我家爱豆,你说他这么多问题,你捐过几毛钱?Isa littlefamiliar-sounding, feels likebeforehandMr.yellow, yellowbiggood man?
是不是有点耳熟呢,有没有感觉像是以前的黄老爷,黄大善人呢?Mr.yellow the heartis friendly, othersrepair the bridge the repair of roads, otherscame across the disaster the bestowmentreliefdisaster victims, absolutelywas the biggood man.
黄老爷心善啊,人家修桥补路,人家遇到天灾了施舍救济灾民,绝对是大大的善人。However, Mr.yellow is also in the city the biggesthuman smuggler, biggestinterest on interestboss.
但是呢,黄老爷也是城里最大的人口贩子,最大的驴打滚儿老板。Therefore, donating money, thatis the biggood man, has not contributedcannotspeaka few words.
所以,捐了款,那就是大善人,没捐过的一律不能说一句话。However, the Yuanelder sistercanunderstand that probablyZhouresoluteidea, others are uncertain.
然而,媛姐大概可以理解周毅的想法,其他人就不一定了。Thislittle whileis facingthisnews, many person'sfirstresponseis, youtread the horseis teasingme? Thisisfalse!
这会儿面对着这个新闻,很多人的第一反应就是,你踏马的在逗我?这是假的吧!
The resultcarefullylooked at the laterdiscovery, othersalsoreal!
结果仔细看了之后发现,人家还就是真的!Moreover, the opposite partysaidcanissueseveryone the Hope School the record of addressas well asdonation, welcomeeveryoneto investigate.
而且,对方说了可以把希望小学地址以及捐赠的记录都发给大家,欢迎大家来调查。However, withoutundergoing the investigationinonlinesaid that rashlythisis certainly false, the opposite partydoes not remove the legalwayto come the rights protection!
但是,如果没有经过调查就在网上贸然说这一定是假的,那对方也不排除走法律途径来维权!
Before putting, the legalwayisto frighten the person, by the present, with the resoluterelatedmatter, few peoplemetto dareto betthis......
放以前,法律途径是吓唬人的,到了现在,和阿毅有关的事,很少有人会敢赌这个……In such a case, jumpedvarioustypesto say the netizen who generallyresoluteshouldbe blockedwasthoroughlyspeechless.
在这样的情况下,广大跳出来各种说阿毅应该被封杀的网友是彻底无语。„Mythis...... the sound that ownfacehits, withoutsaying, apologizedwithresolute, othersalsoreallycontributed, contributed the Hope School, and has not propagandized, was resolute, Icancelled the account number.”
“我这……自己把自己脸打的啪啪响,没说的,跟阿毅道歉,人家还真的就捐了,还是捐了希望小学,而且从来没有宣传过,阿毅牛逼,我自己注销账号吧。”„+ 1, look at the earliestdonationtime, is the opposite partystartsto makeUPLordtime, had not really said that beforescoldedfor a long timesaid that hedid not donate money, originallyothersus, when the monkeylooked that cancelled, the netsailed upstreamis too deep, wecould not grasp......”
“,看最早的捐赠时间,是对方最开始做up主的时候,真的没说的,以前骂了那么久说他不捐款,原来人家把我们当猴子看呢,注销吧,网上水太深,咱把握不住……”Thesestandon own initiative the apology, belonging to the heartis quite big, buttheseare not concerned about facebigV, thatwas needless saying that no matterothershowHeyte, pretendednot to seedirectly.
这些主动站出来道歉的,属于心胸比较大的,而那些不要脸的大v,那就不用说了,不管别人怎么艾特,直接装作没看到。Arrivedevenclosed the commentaryareafinally.
到了最后甚至是关闭了评论区。Feigns death, had/leftsuchreversematterto feign deathin any caseeach time, when the matterpassed, continuedexactly the rottenmoney.
装死呗,反正每次出了这样的反转事情就装死,等事情过去了,继续出来恰烂钱。Butaccordingly, „andresoluteapology”thistopicstarts the heat degreeto rise dramaticallysimilarly.
而相应的,“和阿毅道歉”这个话题同样开始热度飙升。Othersdo not know, the counter-squareMiaolittle missreallyfeels proud and elatednow!
别人不知道,反正方淼小姑娘现在真的是扬眉吐气!„Youdid not say that youdid consult the donationrecordrecent? Said that yousimplyhadn't found? You where checks the uncle? Ireallyadmire the skill that your opening the eyes the eyeis talking nonsensevery much!”
“诶你不是说你查阅了最近几年的捐赠记录吗?说你根本没找到吗?你在哪查的呢大叔?我真的很佩服你们这种睁着眼睛说瞎话的本事呢!”„Howyoudo not speak, youspoke, won't die the uncle?”
“你咋不说话了呢,你说话啊,不会是死了吧大叔?”bellLena the hand of cell phonewas shaking, hesuddenlyfeelsnow,oneselfwassees the wizardto be ablewithresolutesuchcrazedpersonmutuallyresentment.
钟乐拿着手机的手都在抖了,他现在突然觉得,自己是见了鬼才会和阿毅这么丧心病狂的人互怼的。The most important thing is, youtread the horsesincehas sent the videoto be scoldedmanytimes, whyyoudo not takeearlier!
最重要的是,你踏马自从发视频以来被骂了多少次,你为什么不早点拿出来啊!Ifyoutakeearlier, Ias forwill also saysuch?
你要是早点拿出来,那我还至于会说那样的话吗?
Before Zhouresolute, said that hedoes not worry, becausesomepeoplewill worry.
周毅之前说的,他一点都不着急,因为有人会着急。Idonated money, moreoverkept the record, youstand saying that nowyoucheckedhad not recorded, ourcountryalsohad the correspondingstipulationregardingthisaspect, hadhas, has not had.
我捐款了,而且留了记录,你现在站出来说你查了没记录,我们国家对于这方面可是也有相应规定的,有就是有,没有就是没有。Youguess that whowill worry?
那你猜谁会着急呢?Not only the unilateralMiaolittle misstauntedhim, manyresoluteaudiencemastersmessagepunch-.
不单单方淼小姑娘嘲讽他,很多阿毅的观众老爷都来留言打卡了。Clockhappya few wordsdo not dare saying that heis thinkingcanpresentbeforehanddrags.
钟乐一句话不敢说,他想着能不能把现在的事先拖过去。However, although the Internet did not remember, actuallydoes not representeveryoneto have the amnesia.
然而,互联网虽然是没记忆的,却不代表大家都有失忆症。Beforecell phonepreassemblesoftwarethatmattermaynot have, butmanyopinionswere pressedby the beforehandrhythm.
之前手机预装软件那事儿可没有过去,只是很多言论被之前的节奏压了下来。
To forget a matter, the bestmethodsuppresseswithothermaterial.
要想让人忘记一件事,最好的方法是用别的猛料来压制。Inthesematerialseasiest-to-usenaturallywas the starscandal, hundredtried the larksimply!
这些猛料里面最好用的自然是明星绯闻了,简直百试百灵!However, althoughwhile the time of belt/bringrhythm, manyrelatedexpertssaid the preassemblesoftware unable over the two daysall at once, mustaccording to the market conditions, butthisandmoralkidnappingistwo matters!
不过呢,尽管这两天趁着带节奏的功夫,很多相关的专家都说预装软件不能一刀切,得根据市场情况来看,但这和道德绑架是两码事!Thisin the final analysisis the option!
这归根结底是选择权!Everyoneas the consumer, regarding the preassemblesoftware, has the right of free choice!
大家作为消费者,对于预装软件,有自由选择的权利!
During trembles, bellLereceived the companyhrcall.
瑟瑟发抖之中,钟乐接到了公司hr的电话。„What? Letmetalk?”
“什么?让我去谈话?”Althoughsaid that youhave no mistakeprobably, manycompanies are very clear, evenwithoutthisperson, resolutewill still makethisissue of video.
虽然说你好像没什么过错,很多公司都很清楚,就算是没有这个人,阿毅也还是会做这一期视频的。But...... thisdoes not hindereveryonenot to seehisidea.
但……这并不妨碍大家不想看到他的想法。Butexactly, bellLe is just cell phonemanufacturer a constructionengineer of slowapplication......
而恰好,钟乐刚好是其中一家手机厂商的慢应用的架构工程师……
The sentenceis not of pleasant to hear, the interchangeability of his positionisveryhigh, has not imaginedsuch unable to substitute.
说句不好听的,他这个职位的可替代性还是很高的,并没有想象中那样是不能替代。Thisis the present situation of entireindustryat present, because in some sense, sounds the bigonoccupation, is relatedwith the Internet, itstechnique contenthas not actually imaginedis so high.
这是目前整个行业的现状,因为从某种意义上来说,很多听起来高大上的职业,和互联网相关的,它其实技术含量没有想象中那么高。Whatare moreisneedsyouto have a goodbody......
更多的是需要你有一个好身体……Why, the anti-exercise, the programmershad done a 996. ICUwebsite, at that timecaused a stirvery much.
为什么,耐操啊,程序员们曾经搞过一个996.ICU的网站,当时可是很轰动来着。Somepeopleare living, hehas died......
有的人活着,他已经死了……Howeverthishas not calculated,thistime, everyoneexperiencedanythingisearnest.
然而这还不算完,这一次,大家见识到了什么是较真。When„toresoluteapology”thistopicheat degreetocertain extent, some people coming outopposed.
当“向阿毅道歉”这个话题热度到了一定程度之时,有人出来表示反对了。Said that did not misunderstandonetime, whomadehimnot say that whymustapologizewithhim!
说不就是误会了一次嘛,谁让他不说的,凭什么得和他道歉!Finallyshortly aftertheyshut up.
结果没多久他们就闭上了嘴。Because the person with high aspirationsreorganized a videospecially, „whomy”cell phonetakes responsibilityfrommoststarts„to rechargebackhandedlyrecent1 million”, undertheseallvideocommentaryareastauntdonationcommentariesgaveto turn, and after compiling, sent the video.
因为有一个有心人专门整理了一个视频,从最开始的“反手充值一百万”到最近的“我的手机谁做主”,这些所有视频评论区下方的嘲讽捐款评论都给翻了出来,并且汇总之后发了视频。
The titleis: WhyItoldyou to apologize! Scolded for a year, apologizedto have the mistake?
标题就是:我来告诉你为什么得道歉!骂一年了,道个歉有错吗?No words saying, did not have the wordsto saythoroughly, whatwasabnormal, thiswas the realanomaly!
没话说了,彻底没话说了,什么叫变态,这就是真正的变态!resoluteis an earnestlunatic, hisaudience is also the earnestlunatic!
阿毅是个较真的疯子,他的观众也是较真的疯子!Suchvideoso many of oneyear of sending, moreovereachissue of heat degree is so high, commentedto the explosionmany, the opposite partycanleaf throughthesecommentaryareasunexpectedly, scolding the commentary of donationis lookingto compile, thisneededbigwork load.
这么一年发的视频那么多,而且每一期的热度都那么高,评论多到爆炸,对方居然能翻遍这些评论区,把骂着捐款的评论找出来汇总,这需要多大的工作量。Was speechless, was really speechless.
无话可说了,真的是无话可说了。In the company, clear/painbluelooks at this series ofoperations, sighing, the boss is really makes one not be fully correct.
公司里,楚蓝看着这一系列的操作,叹口气,老板真的是让人猜不透呢。Without the rhythm, matterstart of cell phonepreassemblesoftwaremadeeveryoneseeagain,thismatteris not big, even is very to many small, butnow, thisis the important matter!
没有了节奏,手机预装软件的事重新开始让大家看到,这件事不大,甚至对于很多人来说很小,但是现在,这就是大事!Many things, noton the wordsnotfourtwofold of scale, buton the scale, that1000jin (0.5 kg)could not stop!
很多事,不上秤的话没四两重,但是上了秤,那一千斤都打不住!Thesematters that just likeZhouYinongcame outbefore are the same, after sending, everyonerealized, thistreads the horseso that's how it is!
正如之前周毅弄出来的那些事一样,发出来之后大家才意识到,这踏马的原来如此!Somemanypeoplebelieveas before, the resolutethisrights protectionis not goodto do.
只是依旧有很多人认为,阿毅这次维权不好做。Becausehisdemandis not fond of playing jokes, ifraisedsuing of right infringement, thenthisdemandcompensation were too few, becauseothersoccupiedyourmemoryat most, youare unable to show that saidthissituationcaused the biglossestoyou.
因为他的诉求不好弄,如果提起侵权之诉,那么这个诉求赔偿就太少了,因为别人顶多占了你内存,你无法证明说这个情况给你造成了多大的损失。But the solelawsuit, otherscell phonemanufacturerdoes not bringto manageyour.
而单一的诉讼,人家手机厂商根本不带理你的。Firstotherslawsare noteat without working, lostindifferently.
一来人家的法务不是吃干饭的,二来嘛,输了也无所谓啊。Thereforenow, manypeoplewantto know how resolutedoes wantto do?
所以现在,很多人都想知道,阿毅到底要怎么做呢?Zhouresolutehas left the companyto goinhome of brightpeakcommunity, is preparingto holdtwogames, finallycell phonesound.
周毅已经离开公司回了光明峰小区的家里,正准备开两把游戏呢,结果手机响了。„Are you manager in lotus rootpiececompany? Hello, do youlook formearedo do?”
“你是藕片公司的经理?你好,请问你找我是干嘛呢?”Does not needto guess,Zhouresolutehas been ableto think, oppositeabsolutelywithManagerclear/painis a peer, howdoes not know the conscience.
都不用猜,周毅已经能想到,对面这位绝对和楚经理是同行,就是不知道良心咋样。OppositethatManagerorchidsaid with a smile: „Mr.Zhou, your is actually very easy to do, does not needto dosuchin a big way, youthought that somesoftwareare unable to unload, we can helpyouunload.”
对面那位兰经理笑道:“周先生,其实您这个很好办的,没有必要搞这么大,您觉得有的软件无法卸载,那我们可以让人帮您卸载的。”
The help, howhelps, naturallywasroot.
帮忙,怎么帮,自然是root了。Theoretically, after root, youcanhave the managerjurisdiction of cell phone, howwantsto dohowto do.
理论上来说,root之后你就可以拥有手机的管理员权限,想怎么搞怎么搞。Whymanycell phoneswill turn into the brick, after isroot, tampered with.
很多手机为什么会变成砖头,就是root之后瞎搞了。Whatis the differencetreats, thisis the differencetreats.
什么是区别对待,这就是区别对待。Manypeopleare not willingto accept, thinks that thesebigcompaniesshouldtreat impartiallytoeachcustomer, actually do oneselfthinkthispossibility?
很多人不愿意接受,认为这些大公司应该对每一个客户都是一视同仁的,其实自己心里想想这可能吗?
The bankis fierce, howyouhave a look at the super client and ordinarycustomerotherstreat.
银行厉不厉害,你看看大客户和普通客户人家是怎么对待的。Moreoveryoutocompel the place that shoutedand so onto looksimilarly, will frequently seebankers'speech.
而且你到类似逼呼之类的地方去看,经常会看到银行从业人员的发言。
The bankmakes moneyisdepends on the super clientto gain, someyoungprivate investorscannot make money, but alsodislikesthissuspicion that counterservice not goodthatservice is not right.
银行赚钱就是靠着大客户赚的,一些小散户根本赚不到钱,还嫌这嫌那,柜台这服务不好那服务不对。This saying to be right, wedo not know,after all is not the specialists.
这话对不对,咱也不知道,毕竟不是专业人员。However the differencetreatsto existin various trades and occupations!
但是区别对待存在于各行各业!resoluteis a big netis red, thereforeheaftersendingrelatedvideo, othersare thinkingsolveshim.
阿毅是个大网红,所以他在发了相关视频后,人家就会想着来解决他。So long assolvedperson who asked the issue, thatissuenaturallyalsonot.
只要解决了提出问题的人,那问题自然也就不在了。Ifresolutecandelete the video, thatthismatterstoppednaturally.
阿毅如果能把视频删了,那自然而然这件事就到此为止了。Althoughseemedno one to makeresolutein the pastdelete the video......
虽然过去好像没人能让阿毅删视频……HoweverManagerorchidis very confident, shesimilarlyis the toppublic relations manager!
但是兰经理很有信心,她同样是顶级的公关经理!„Managerorchid, Ialwaysquitestraight talk from a straightforward person, wesaiddirectly, yousaiddefinitelydoes not understandme, ifIonlythinkto unload, Iwill be impossibleto makethistest!”
“兰经理,我这个人一向比较快言快语,咱们直接说吧,你这么说肯定是不了解我,我如果只想自己卸载,那我不可能会做这个测试!”„Ido not needyouto helpmeunload, Iwantto letonyourcell phones, according to the stipulation, canmake the consumerunload, the consumermusthavethisright!”
“我并不是需要你们帮我卸载,我是想让你们的手机上,按照规定,能让消费者卸载的,消费者必须有这个权利!”Is earnest, thatonce and for allearnest, solelywascanunloadisanything.
要较真,那就一劳永逸地较真,单单是自己能卸载了算什么。Let aloneI , to unloadmealso to look foryou? Found a placeto brush the machinenoton the line.
更何况我如果想卸载我还要找你们?找个地方刷机不就行了嘛。„It is not, Mr.Zhou, youlistened tome saying that yourbeforehandmatterIknow, butthisdifference, Iwasforyouconsideredsincerely, yousuedourcompanyeven, ordisposablesuedallcell phonemanufacturers, how can also?”
“不是,周先生,您听我说,您以前的事我都知道,但是这次不一样,我是诚心为您考虑的,你就算是起诉我们公司,或者一次性把所有手机厂商都起诉了,又能如何呢?”„Youcannot attainanythingto compensateright, to you are the gain does not equal the loss, butus, so long asyoucomply to delete the video, howthatsaid......”
“您也拿不到什么赔偿对吧,对于您来说就是得不偿失的,而我们这边,只要您答应能删除视频,那怎么都好说……”
The voice of Managerorchidis very of pleasant to hear, butZhouresolutedoes not wantto listen.
兰经理的声音很好听,但是周毅不想听了。Managerclear/painis listeningenough.
有一个楚经理听着就够了。„Managerorchid, thatthis, myhowrights protectionnaturallyhasmymethod.”
“兰经理,那就这样吧,我怎么维权自然有我的方法。”„ButMr.Zhou, you, no matter the prosecutiondoes not sue, thevideo that yousendhas seriously affected the reputation of ourcompany, this...... reallywantsto cooperatewithyou.”Managerorchidsaidagain.
“可是周先生,你不管起诉不起诉,你发的这个视频已经严重影响到了我们公司的声誉,这个……真的还是想和您合作的。”兰经理再次说道。„...... Hung.”
“……挂了。”
The failing to agreehalf a wordwords, after Zhouresolute decided that regardingtheseso-calledpublic relations managertelephonedirectlhasas to heiho.
话不投机半句话,周毅决定以后对于这些所谓的公关经理电话直接拉黑。Twothinkto understand itself, the resultopened mouthanythinggives the exposition.
一个两个都以为了解自己,结果一张嘴把什么都给暴露了。Another side, Managerorchidlooks at the cell phone that hangs up, shakes the head, thisjustcontacted, is notanything.
另一边,兰经理看着挂断的手机,摇摇头,这才刚刚接触而已,不算什么。Had the person of this viewpoint is too many, becausetrulyasindividual, youreallythinks that the earnestwords, basicallynot possibleto have any tremendous impact on others.
持有她这种观点的人太多了,因为确实作为个人来说,你真的想较真到底的话,基本上不可能对人家造成什么大的影响。But, Jingzhou Intermediate People's Court, the man (Han)chancellerydisappeared the requestattorneys in insuranceentrust/windingto go to the registration hallin such a case.
而就在这样的情况下,京州市中院,汉东省消保委的委托律师来到了立案大厅。Thisattorneywears the gold-rimmed eyeglasses, heada littleslightlycool, looksgivespeople a veryfiercefeeling!
这位律师戴着金丝眼镜,头上有点微凉,看着就给人一种十分厉害的感觉!sideDazhuanggoes into actionpersonally, hitsthispublic welfare lawsuitlawsuit!
方大状亲自出马,来打这个公益诉讼官司了!Asked the monthly ticket, todayrenews, tomorrowwill continue!
求月票啦,今天更新完毕,明天继续!Thank the bookfriend2021, bookfriend2022, hitting of sleepless nightthreebrothersenjoyed, thanks
感谢书友2021,书友2022,不眠夜三位兄弟的打赏,谢谢
( This chapterends)
(本章完)
To display comments and comment, click at the button
Comments for Chapter #343: Some people are living, he has died